Use Nails, Not Staples

Roofing shingles play a crucial role in protecting our homes from the elements. Over the years, various methods have been employed to secure shingles to roofs, with one old practice involving the use of large staples. However, as construction practices and roofing materials have evolved, it has become evident that this traditional approach has significant drawbacks. In this article, we will explore why the use of large staples to attach roofing shingles is considered a bad idea in modern roofing.

1. Lack of Proper Fastening:

One of the primary drawbacks of using large staples for roofing shingles is their limited ability to provide proper fastening. Unlike modern roofing nails, which have specifically designed heads and shafts to securely hold shingles in place, staples lack the necessary structural features. The flat, wide heads of staples do not offer sufficient holding power, leading to an increased risk of shingle uplift during high winds or severe weather conditions.

    2. Reduced Wind Resistance:

Roofing shingles are vulnerable to wind uplift, particularly in areas prone to strong gusts or storms. Large staples, due to their design and limited holding capacity, are unable to effectively counteract the forces exerted by wind. As a result, shingles attached with staples may become loose or even detach from the roof, compromising the integrity of the roofing system and exposing the underlying structure to potential damage.

    3. Inadequate Penetration and Stability:

Proper installation of roofing shingles involves securely fastening them to the roof deck. Staples, with their shorter length and limited penetration capability, fail to achieve the necessary stability. Unlike roofing nails, which can penetrate through multiple layers of shingles and firmly anchor them to the roof, staples provide a shallow grip that is more susceptible to dislodgement over time. This can lead to shingle displacement, water infiltration, and subsequent roof leaks.

    4. Compatibility Issues:

Modern roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles, are designed to work optimally with specific fastening methods. Manufacturers provide guidelines on the recommended attachment systems, and the use of large staples may not be compatible with these guidelines. Staples may cause damage to the shingles, compromising their performance and potentially voiding warranties provided by the shingle manufacturer.

    5.Aesthetics and Resale Value:

Large staples can have a negative impact on the appearance of the roof. They may create visible punctures or dimples on the surface of the shingles, detracting from the overall aesthetics of the roof. This can be particularly problematic when it comes to selling the property, as potential buyers may be deterred by the compromised visual appeal and consider it a red flag in terms of the roof's quality and maintenance.

Conclusion:

While the practice of using large staples to attach roofing shingles may have been prevalent in the past, it is now widely regarded as a poor choice. The lack of proper fastening, reduced wind resistance, inadequate penetration and stability, compatibility issues, and negative impact on aesthetics and resale value all contribute to the conclusion that large staples are not suitable for modern roofing applications. Instead, it is recommended to follow industry best practices and use roofing nails specifically designed to provide secure and long-lasting attachment, ensuring the integrity and durability of the roofing system.